Bella 35258 vs Presto 06857 Electric Skillet
The Bella 35258 and the Presto 06857 are two of the most-reviewed electric skillets on the market, and they attract buyers for different reasons. The Bella comes in at $49.99 with a stainless steel build and a distinctive plum finish, while the Presto costs $89.99 and leans on a larger aluminum cooking surface and higher wattage. Both carry very strong ratings from tens of thousands of buyers, so neither is a risky pick. The real question is whether the Presto's extra power and size are worth paying $40 more.
Quick winner
The Presto 06857 is the better pick for anyone who cooks for a crowd or wants faster, higher-wattage performance; the Bella 35258 wins on value and counter-space friendliness.
Key differences, measured
- The Bella 35258 is 44% cheaper ($49.99 vs $89.99).
- The Presto 06857 is 300 W higher (1500 W vs 1200 W).
- The Presto 06857 is 1.5 lb heavier (8.55 lb vs 7.1 lb).
- Amazon buyers rate the Presto 06857 0.2 stars higher across 32,500 combined reviews.
Side-by-side specs
| Spec | Bella 35258 Electric Skillet | Presto 06857 Electric Skillet |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $49.99 | $89.99 |
| Rating | ||
| Wattage | 1200 W | 1500 W |
| Material | Stainless Steel | Aluminum |
| Color | Plum | Black |
| Dimensions | 12.4 X 16.22 X 6.89 In | 12 X 20 X 8.1 In |
| Weight | 7.1 lb | 8.55 lb |
| Voltage | 120 Volts (Ac) | 120.0 |
The two contenders
Bella 35258 Electric Skillet
The Bella 35258 is priced at $49.99 and draws 1200 watts, making it a solid everyday skillet that keeps electricity draw modest. It measures 12.4 by 16.22 by 6.89 inches and weighs 7.1 pounds, a manageable footprint for most kitchens. The stainless steel construction gives it a sturdy feel, and the plum color sets it apart from the sea of plain black appliances. With a 4.5-star rating across more than 16,600 reviews, its owner satisfaction record is genuinely impressive for a sub-$50 skillet.
Buy this if: The Bella 35258 is a good fit for singles, couples, or small families who want a capable electric skillet without spending $90. If counter space is limited or you prefer a lighter, more compact unit, the Bella's smaller footprint and 7.1-pound weight make it easier to move and store. The lower price also leaves room in the budget if you ever want to replace it.
Check price on AmazonPresto 06857 Electric Skillet
The Presto 06857 retails for $89.99 and runs at 1500 watts, giving it 25 percent more power than the Bella for faster preheat and better heat recovery between batches. Its dimensions of 12 by 20 by 8.1 inches make it noticeably longer, which suits cooking bigger proteins or feeding four to six people in a single pass. At 8.55 pounds it is heavier than the Bella, so storage and handling are worth considering. The Presto carries a 4.7-star average from roughly 15,900 reviews, the highest rating in this comparison.
Buy this if: The Presto 06857 suits households that cook larger meals regularly or want the confidence of higher wattage for searing and browning. If you regularly cook for four or more people and want a skillet with a long, roomy cooking surface, the 20-inch length of the Presto is a meaningful advantage. Buyers who prioritize the highest owner-satisfaction rating in the category and are willing to pay a premium for it will also find the Presto a comfortable choice.
Check price on AmazonFrequently asked questions
Which skillet has more cooking power, the Bella 35258 or the Presto 06857?
The Presto 06857 draws 1500 watts compared to 1200 watts for the Bella 35258. That 300-watt difference means the Presto heats up faster and recovers temperature more quickly after you add cold food. For everyday tasks like eggs or sauteed vegetables the gap matters less, but for browning meat or cooking larger batches it is a real advantage.
How big is the Bella 35258 compared to the Presto 06857?
The Bella 35258 measures 12.4 by 16.22 by 6.89 inches and the Presto 06857 measures 12 by 20 by 8.1 inches. The Presto is about four inches longer and slightly taller, which gives it a larger cooking surface. If cabinet or counter space is tight, the Bella's more compact size is easier to manage.
Is the Bella 35258 or the Presto 06857 rated higher by owners?
The Presto 06857 holds a 4.7-star rating from approximately 15,900 reviews, while the Bella 35258 sits at 4.5 stars from over 16,600 reviews. Both ratings are strong, but the Presto edges ahead in average score. The Bella leads slightly in total review volume, which is notable given that it is a newer product at a lower price point.
Which skillet offers better value for the money?
At $49.99, the Bella 35258 costs $40 less than the Presto 06857 at $89.99. The Bella delivers 1200 watts, a stainless steel build, and a 4.5-star rating, which is strong performance for the price. The Presto justifies its higher cost with extra wattage, a longer cooking surface, and a slightly better owner rating. If budget is the primary concern, the Bella is the clearer value; if you cook larger meals often, the Presto's premium is easier to justify.