Hamilton Beach 25371 Electric Grill Review
Our verdict
The Hamilton Beach 25371 is a practical, well-priced indoor electric grill at $54.99 that has earned a strong 4.4-star average from over 5500 buyers, one of the largest review pools in this category. It delivers 1200 watts on a standard 120-volt outlet, making it immediately compatible with North American kitchens.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Everyday indoor grilling for one to three people who want a reliable, no-frills grill at an accessible price. It suits renters and small households that need a compact footprint of 6.38 x 12.68 x 13.78 inches and do not want to invest heavily in a countertop appliance.
Skip if
Skip this if you regularly cook large batches or thick cuts that demand more than 1200 watts for fast searing. Buyers who prioritize premium materials over value will likely want to look at higher-priced options.
- Wattage 1200 W
- Material Metal, Plastic, Stainless Steel
- Color Silver
- Dimensions 6.38 X 12.68 X 13.78 In
- Weight 5.0 lb
- Voltage 120
- Priced 46% below the category median ($101.98 across 36 tracked models)
- Wattage of 1200 W - lower than 72% of the 36 models we track
- Weight of 5.0 lb - lighter than 67% of the 36 models we track
Pros
- 5500-plus buyer ratings at 4.4 stars reflects a large, well-validated audience
- Compatible with standard 120-volt North American outlets, no adapters needed
- Lightweight at 5 lb, easy to store and bring out for meals
- Price of $54.99 makes it one of the most accessible grills in this silo
- Compact dimensions work on small counters and apartment kitchens
Cons
- 1200 watts is moderate, so heat recovery between batches may be slower than higher-wattage units
- Plastic components in the construction reduce the premium feel
- No published specs for cooking surface area, making direct size comparisons difficult
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.4/5
4.4 average across 5,500 owner ratings
-
Popularity4.7/5
5,500 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other air fryers, deep fryers, indoor grills, griddles and countertop cooking appliances we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Specifications
- Wattage
- 1200 W
- Material
- Metal, Plastic, Stainless Steel
- Color
- Silver
- Dimensions
- 6.38 X 12.68 X 13.78 In
- Weight
- 5.0 lb
- Voltage
- 120
Overview
The Hamilton Beach 25371 occupies a smart spot in the market: enough power at 1200 watts to handle everyday grilling, a manageable 5-pound weight for easy handling, and a price that removes most of the financial risk. The stainless steel, metal, and plastic construction is typical of this price tier and keeps weight down without making the unit feel flimsy.
Performance notes
At 1200 watts on a 120-volt circuit, this grill reaches cooking temperatures suitable for burgers, chicken breasts, vegetables, and fish. It is not designed for high-heat steakhouse searing but performs reliably for weeknight meals. The 5-pound weight means it stays stable on a countertop during use without requiring excessive counter anchoring. The combination of stainless steel and metal framing provides enough structural integrity for daily use.
What buyers say
Over 5500 ratings averaging 4.4 stars makes the Hamilton Beach 25371 one of the most reviewed grills in this price range. That volume of feedback across a diverse buyer base is a strong indicator of consistent, repeatable performance. Buyers at this price point generally accept that the build is functional rather than premium, and the rating suggests most find the performance-to-price balance satisfying.
More from Hamilton Beach
Similar air fryers, deep fryers, indoor grills, griddles and countertop cooking appliances to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
Is the Hamilton Beach 25371 easy to clean?
The removable components on Hamilton Beach grills in this series are generally straightforward to wipe down. Check whether the grill plates detach on your specific unit before purchase, as cleaning ease varies by model configuration. A damp cloth handles most post-cooking residue on the cooking surface.
Can it handle grilling for a family of four?
For four people, you will likely need to cook in two batches given the compact footprint. The 1200-watt output maintains reasonable cooking temperatures between batches, but expect slightly longer total cook times than with a larger-surface, higher-wattage unit.
How does the 25371 compare to the Hamilton Beach 25360MNA?
Both are 1200-watt, 120-volt Hamilton Beach grills at similar price tiers. The 25360MNA has a significantly larger buyer pool with over 31,000 ratings, suggesting longer market tenure. The 25371 is slightly smaller and lighter at 5 lb versus 8.15 lb, which may matter if you store the grill frequently.